Hide Three days left! Support our fundraiser by January 5th and get the first BestNetTech Commemorative Coin »

The Reckoning At The Town Hall

from the the-truth-still-wants-to-be-heard dept

The footage is hard to watch—not because it’s shocking, but because it isn’t.

Because we’ve seen this coming.

Because we’ve written it down.

Because it’s what happens when performance fully replaces governance, and people are asked to believe that “DOGE” and “efficiency” and “Musk” now constitute a new political grammar.

Rep. Victoria Spartz stands in front of her constituents at a town hall in Indiana.

She talks about Elon Musk running government systems.

She invokes the Department of Government Efficiency — a shell entity, a fever-dream turned administrative body.

And she is booed.

Not politely disagreed with. Not civilly challenged.

Booed.

She tells them they should have “a conversation.”

But they’ve seen enough.

They’re no longer there for conversation.

They’ve come—as someone once said—for a reckoning.

Because this isn’t about decorum anymore.

It’s not about whether the line of questioning is appropriate or whether the tone is right.

It’s about the slow, quiet realization that the thing they thought they were part of—

government, democracy, accountability

is being replaced.

Replaced with tweets and deferrals.

With “tech visionary” as a synonym for “unaccountable executive power.”

With a Department of Government Efficiency that answers to no one.

With decisions made inside encrypted group chats where war plans get shared by accident.

With a Treasury system reportedly “more innovative” now that it’s not public.

And when a member of Congress defends this —

defends it by invoking dogecoin as the marker of progress —

something in the room breaks.

Not trust. That’s already gone.

What breaks is the spell.

The illusion that there’s still a shared script.

That the adults are still in the room.

That this is all just part of the process, that it’s still governed by rules.

No.

This is not a conversation anymore.

This is the circus, unmasked.

And so they boo.

Not because they’re disrespectful.

But because they’re mourning something that used to be sacred.

They boo because the wire snapped, and the performer pretended nothing happened.

Because the tent is tilting, and the ringleaders are pointing to the lighting rig and saying,

“But look how efficient it is.”

What Spartz fails to understand is that this town hall wasn’t disorderly.

It was the return of moral rhythm.

The refusal to remain audience members to their own disenfranchisement.

They didn’t come to be spoken to.

They came to speak.

And their voices—those strained, unpolished, interrupted voices—were the only true things in the room.

So let this be the Note, passed quietly after the shouting.

Let it carry this message:

The people are not fooled.

They see the circus for what it is.

And they know that meaning, once abandoned, cannot be governed by efficiency.

Two plus two equals four.

There are twenty-four hours in a day.

And even here—amid the clamor, amid the spectacle—

the truth still wants to be heard.

Even in a room that couldn’t speak it.

Especially there.

Mike Brock is a former tech exec who was on the leadership team at Block. Originally published at his Notes From the Circus.

Filed Under: , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “The Reckoning At The Town Hall”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
11 Comments
Justsnotherpeon says:

The re Kooning was many years ago

So now you’re angry? Did it ever occur to you that both sides of the aisle purposely created this disaster and that this Frankenstein monster is a direct result? 40+ years of neoliberalism that has destroyed the American worker, sent all good paying jobs overseas, and destroyed the unions. The creation of a global billionaire class that no longer is bound by any nation or laws and completely owns the entire political machinery of most nations and their reward to us is poverty, starvation, a police state, and planetary wars and pandemics that are killing tens of millions for their insatiable greed and cruelty.

The entire system is collapsing and no one is going to rescue you or me. Especially not the Democrats and Republicans who are in complete thrall to these billionaires. Your only choice now is whether you are going to be a servant, a serf or a slave.

ECA (profile) says:

Re: Neo?

All this did what?
I lived thru the time you are talking about, and know what happened and How Most of it was created.
#1 Corps ran away, when the gov. ASKED them to Cleanup the Nesses they were making. INCLUDING our rivers, Which are STILL not cleaned up With Dammed Poison Lakes around the nation, ready to break. EITHER THEY CLEAN IT UP, or the Gov. has to do it.
#2 Corps dont like to Loose money, and they have Slowly had restrictions, laws, regulations CUT. And the Gov Agencies Cut back to nothing and NO backbone.

Do you even Care if a Dairy farm Plants itself on land and Just Does its thing, above your Aquafer?
Or Corp farmers use Enough poison that in 10 years(its been 50 since the Chemicals were started) Those Chemicals End up in the Aquafer you are getting your drinking water from?
Or how about Fracking 5 miles from your Home, Within 10 miles of an Aquafer? Most Gas fumes have NO SMELL, except what we Put into it. It can filll your home, while you take a Shower, you sit down and light a Cig.. BOOM.
Other Countries have MUCH better regulations and Control. and the Corps DONT Bitch as Much.

bhull242 (profile) says:

Re:

Did it ever occur to you that both sides of the aisle purposely created this disaster and that this Frankenstein monster is a direct result?

Only one side is deliberately breaking the system and causing problems as a result. The system—for all its flaws—still worked better than what we have now, so it is disingenuous to blame the current disaster on anyone’s work in past administrations.

40+ years of neoliberalism that has destroyed the American worker, sent all good paying jobs overseas, and destroyed the unions.

That is an entirely separate and unrelated issue. Also, it was conservatives destroying unions, not neoliberalism, and the jobs sent overseas weren’t the “good-paying” ones so much as the labor-intensive ones.

Connedsumer (profile) says:

Can we be serious for a moment?

Come on, Mike. I know you are pissed. Too many unwanted changes to soon, but booing at politicians saying unpopular things is probably older than the US.

Not to mention shutting down disagreeable voices is all the rage on campuses nationwide. Who runs those again? Is it MAGA.

If the focus is indeed to whine about pissed-off voters and not how to get them to vote Democrat again, MAGA will indeed be running colleges in less than 4 years. Even if indirectly, like at Columbia.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
MrWilson (profile) says:

Re: Re:

And notably, the things being smashed aren’t just norms and practices – it’s human rights, it’s funding that saves lives, it’s cancer research, it’s food for poor children, it’s education for poor people, it’s our balance of power, it’s our electoral system, it’s our national security, it’s our social security, it’s our relations with allies, it’s the health of our children, etc., et al.

This comment has been deemed insightful by the community.
That One Guy (profile) says:

Defend terrible people and acts, get boo'd for it, go figure

She tells them they should have “a conversation.

Good idea in general, however…

From the source article:
Rep. Victoria Spartz (R-IN) was the latest lawmaker to find herself facing a fiery town hall crowd as she refused to call for Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s resignation and she defended Elon Musk’s work with the administration.

At a Friday town hall in Indiana, Spartz was booed and jeered at a two hour town hall where she defended both Hegseth and Musk’s work with DOGE (Department of Government Efficiency).

She wasn’t there to have a conversation, she was there to tell the voters that all that ‘liquid’ being sprayed all over them was most certainly water, and that anyone telling them otherwise was lying to them.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a BestNetTech Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

BestNetTech community members with BestNetTech Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the BestNetTech Insider Shop »

Follow BestNetTech

BestNetTech Daily Newsletter

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get all our posts in your inbox with the BestNetTech Daily Newsletter!

We don’t spam. Read our privacy policy for more info.

Ctrl-Alt-Speech

A weekly news podcast from
Mike Masnick & Ben Whitelaw

Subscribe now to Ctrl-Alt-Speech »
BestNetTech needs your support! Get the first BestNetTech Commemorative Coin with donations of $100
BestNetTech Deals
BestNetTech Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the BestNetTech Insider Discord channel...
Loading...